The topic of giving money instead of traditional gifts on special occasions is increasingly appearing in IELTS Writing Task 2 exams. Based on recent test reports and candidate experiences, this topic has appeared multiple times in different variations over the past few years, particularly in Asian test centers. Let’s examine a recent question that represents this theme well.
Analysis of Topic and Question
Some people think it is better to give money as gifts for special occasions like birthdays and weddings rather than buying presents. Do you agree or disagree with this opinion?
This question requires candidates to take a clear position on whether giving money is preferable to giving traditional presents. It’s a direct agree/disagree question that needs a well-supported argument with relevant examples.
Comparison between giving money and traditional gifts on special occasions
Band 8.5 Sample Essay
Modern society has witnessed an ongoing debate about whether monetary gifts are more appropriate than traditional presents for special occasions. While both forms of giving have their merits, I firmly believe that giving traditional presents is generally more meaningful and valuable than simply offering money.
The primary advantage of giving actual presents lies in the thoughtfulness and personal touch they represent. When someone carefully selects a gift, they must consider the recipient’s interests, needs, and preferences, demonstrating genuine care and attention. For instance, if someone knows their friend is an aspiring photographer, gifting a vintage camera or photography book shows they have invested time and effort in understanding and supporting the recipient’s passion. This personal connection and emotional investment cannot be replicated by simply writing a check or transferring money electronically.
Furthermore, traditional presents often create lasting memories and emotional associations that money cannot match. A specially chosen item can become a cherished possession that reminds the recipient of both the occasion and the relationship with the gift-giver. For example, a handcrafted piece of jewelry or a rare book collection can become family heirlooms passed down through generations, carrying stories and emotional significance that far exceed their monetary value.
However, I acknowledge that in certain cultural contexts or specific situations, monetary gifts may be more appropriate. In many Asian cultures, giving money in red envelopes during festivals or weddings is a respected tradition that symbolizes good fortune. Additionally, for practical purposes, such as helping newlyweds establish their household or supporting students with their education, financial gifts can be more beneficial than material presents.
In conclusion, while monetary gifts have their place in certain circumstances, I maintain that thoughtfully chosen traditional presents generally offer greater emotional value and create more meaningful connections between people. The effort, consideration, and personal touch involved in selecting an appropriate gift make it a more profound expression of care and appreciation.
Analysis of Band 8.5 Essay
- Clear position maintained throughout
- Sophisticated vocabulary and complex structures
- Well-developed arguments with specific examples
- Excellent paragraph organization and cohesion
- Natural transitions between ideas
- Appropriate formal academic tone
Person carefully selecting a personalized gift in a store
Band 6.5 Sample Essay
In modern times, there is a big discussion about whether we should give money or presents for special occasions. In my opinion, I think giving money is better than buying presents in most situations.
Firstly, when we give money, the receiver can buy what they really want. Sometimes when we buy presents, we might choose something that the other person doesn’t like or already has. For example, if we give money to someone for their birthday, they can save it or use it to buy something they really need. This is more practical than giving them a present they might never use.
Another reason why giving money is better is because it saves time. We don’t need to spend hours going to different shops to find the right gift. Also, in busy cities where many people work long hours, it’s difficult to find time for shopping. Giving money is quick and easy, and we can still show we care about the person.
However, some people think giving presents is more special because it shows more effort and thinking about the other person. They say that money gifts are too cold and don’t have personal meaning. This is true sometimes, but I think in today’s modern world, most people prefer having the freedom to choose what they want.
In conclusion, I believe giving money as gifts is better than buying presents because it is more practical and saves time. Although some people prefer traditional presents, money gives people more choice about what they want to buy.
Analysis of Band 6.5 Essay
- Clear but simple position
- Basic vocabulary with some repetition
- Simple examples and explanations
- Basic paragraph structure
- Simple linking words
- Informal tone at times
Key Vocabulary for IELTS Writing Task 2
- cherished (adj) /ˈtʃerɪʃt/ – valued, protected, loved
- monetary (adj) /ˈmʌnɪteri/ – relating to money
- profound (adj) /prəˈfaʊnd/ – deep, intense
- heirloom (n) /ˈeəluːm/ – valuable object passed down through generations
- thoughtfulness (n) /ˈθɔːtfʊlnəs/ – consideration for others
- practical (adj) /ˈpræktɪkəl/ – useful, suitable for actual use
- appropriate (adj) /əˈprəʊpriət/ – suitable, proper
- significance (n) /sɪɡˈnɪfɪkəns/ – importance, meaning
Future Practice Topics
Consider practicing with these related topics:
- The impact of digital gifts in modern society
- Traditional gift-giving customs in different cultures
- The role of materialism in gift-giving
- Environmental impact of gift-giving practices
Feel free to write your own essay response to the question above and share it in the comments for feedback and discussion.
